Phone Numbers and Websites
The following is a list of toll-free telephone numbers and websites at which interested consumers may contact automobile insurance companies. The companies listed make up 90% of the private passenger automobile insurance marketplace (by premium volume) in New York State. Insurers indicated as “Agents Listed” may be found in a local telephone directory under their direct agencies. Insurers denoted with an asterisk (*) do not offer the ability to obtain a quote or purchase a policy directly through their website.
Information on insurers not listed here may be obtained by contacting licensed insurance agents or brokers.
Company NameTelephone NumberWebsiteA. Central Insurance Co.1-800-234-6926www.nycm.comAllmerica Financial Alliance Insurance Co.*1-800-992-8427www.hanover.comAllstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Co.1-800-255-7828www.allstate.comAllstate Insurance Co.*1-800-255-7828www.allstate.comAmerican Family Connect Insurance Co.1-800-535-2001www.connectbyamfam.comAmerican States Insurance Co.1-800-295-2723www.libertymutual.comAmica Mutual Insurance Co.1-800-242-6422www.amica.comChubb National Insurance Co.*1-866-324-8222www.chubb.com/personalCitizens Insurance Co. of America1-800-922-8427www.hanover.comCountry-Wide Insurance Co.*1-800-796-9288www.cwico.comErie Insurance Co. of New York1-800-458-0811www.erieinsurance.comErie Insurance Co.1-800-458-0811www.erieinsurance.comFarmers Group Property and Casualty Insurance Co.*1-844-296-9644www.myautohome.farmers.comFarmers Property & Casualty Insurance Co.*1-844-296-9644www.myautohome.farmers.comForemost Signature Insurance Co.1-888-888-0080www.foremost.comGarrison Property and Casualty Insurance Co.1-800-531-8722www.usaa.comGEICO General Insurance Co.1-800-841-3000www.geico.comGEICO Indemnity Co.1-800-841-3000www.geico.comGovernment Employees Insurance Co.1-800-841-3000www.geico.comHartford Casualty Insurance Co.1-888-413-8970www.thehartford.comHartford Underwriters Insurance Co.1-888-546-9099www.thehartford.comLM General Insurance Co.1-800-295-2723www.libertymutual.comLM Insurance Corporation1-800-295-2723www.libertymutual.comMain Street America Protection Insurance Co.*1-800-258-5310www.msainsurance.comMassachusetts Bay Insurance Co.1-800-922-8427www.hanover.comMid-Century Insurance Co.1-800-974-6755www.farmers.comNationwide Affinity Insurance Co. of America*1-877-669-6877www.nationwide.comNationwide General Insurance Co.1-877-669-6877www.nationwide.comNew York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Co.1-800-234-6926www.nycm.comPalisades Insurance Co.1-844-242-3555www.plymouthrock.comPlymouth Rock Assurance Corporation of New Yok1-844-242-3555www.plymouthrock.comPlymouth Rock Assurance Preferred Corporation*1-833-511-7625www.plymouthrock.comPreferred Mutual Insurance Co.*1-800-333-7642www.preferredmutual.comProgressive Advanced Insurance Co.1-866-302-4010www.progressive.comProgressive Casualty Insurance*1-800-876-5581www.progressiveagent.comProgressive Max Insurance Co.1-800-888-7764www.progressive.comProgressive Specialty Insurance Co.1-800-876-5581www.progressiveagent.comRepublic Franklin Insurance Co.1-800-598-8422www.uticanational.comState Farm Fire and Casualty Co.Agents Listedwww.statefarm.comState Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.Agents Listedwww.statefarm.comThe Hanover Insurance Co.1-800-922-8427www.hanover.comTravelers Personal Insurance Co.1-866-522-1338www.travelers.comTrumbull Insurance Co.1-888-413-8970www.thehartford.comUnited Services Automobile Association1-800-531-8222www.usaa.comUnitrin Safeguard Insurance Co.*1-877-252-7878www.kemper.comUSAA Casualty Insurance Co.1-800-531-8722www.usaa.comUSAA General Indemnity Co.1-800-531-8722www.usaa.comUtica Mutual Insurance Co.1-800-598-8422www.uticanational.comUtica National Insurance Co. of Texas*1-800-598-8422www.uticanational.com
